Next Stop: Anita's Kitchen

"Hoosier Pie" Trail - Stop 1

Ahlemeyer Farms Olde Tyme Bakery Main Image

Ahlemeyer Farms Olde Tyme Bakery

2034 17th Street
Columbus, IN 47201

Phone Number: 812-372-PIES(7437)

Hours of Operation

Monday- Friday 8am-6pm
Saturday 8am-3pm
Closed Sunday

General Dining

Credit Cards: Visa/ MC/ Amex/ Discover
Meals Served: N/A
Dining Classification: Carryout
Menu Style: Bakery
Alcohol Served:None
Separate Bar Area: No
Largest Group Served:10
Meeting Room Capacity:N/A
Local / Organic:N/A
Diet Specific: low sugar items available


Parking: Parking Lot
Visible Signage: From Road / Sign on Building
Handicapped Accessible: Yes


Seating: None
Hostess on Duty: Always
Gift Shop / Products for Sale: Products for Sale
Smoking: No
Bathrooms: No

Recommended Dishes

Sugar Cream Pie, Kentucky Chocolate Pie, Meringue Pies, Rhubarb Pie, Red Raspberry Pie

Kim Kiel and family started out selling produce. Where they were finding that a lot of the produce that hadnt gone bad, but was not perfect for market, was getting thrown away. In hopes to preserve the produce, the idea came about to start using this food to make bakery items. One thing lead to another and the bakery business was growing faster than the produce. As a result of this growth Ahlemeyer Farms Bakery was established in 1989.

All of the delicious pies are made from scratch where pie shells are hand mixed and rolled out. They are also made using farm fresh ingredients and consist almost entirely of local fruit.

The bakery has been a lot of hard work for many years as well as a great blessing and pleasure for Kim and family.

The Ahlemeyer Farms Bakery family looks forward to serving customers for many more years to come.


Blog Entries: