Indiana Culinary Trails

Stop 18: Tenderloin Lovers Trail Trail


New Castle's most refined dining destination Located on Broad Street in downtown New Castle, Indiana, Primo offers Italian cuisine with a fusion twist. Spaghetti with Meatballs in Marinara and Lasagna Bolognese are made in house, daily. We also feature specialties such as the Salmon Risotto, Chicken Parmesan, and our own Hoosier Tenderloin!

We are open Wednesday through Friday for lunch and dinner and Saturday for dinner. We feature daily lunch combinations of our delicious salads, sandwiches and soups, as well as frequent dinner and drink specials.

At Primo we strive to be a comfortable, yet upscale environment perfect for a date night but also great for family dinner.

Our private dining room, the "125 Room", comfortably seats approximately 30 people. Host your event in our 125 room any day of the week. For larger parties, exclusive private reservations are available Sunday, Monday, and Tuesday. We also offer off site catering services. We would love to host your celebration, meeting or other event.

Hours of Operation



Reservations Recommended



Closed for private events

Sunday, Monday, & Tuesday


Wednesday - Thursday

11:30 am to 2:00 pm

5:00 pm to 8:00 pm


11:30 am to 2:00 pm

5:00 pm to 9:00 pm



5:00 pm to 9:00 pm

General Dining

Credit Cards: Yes

Meals Served: Lunch and Dinner

Dining Classification: Casual Family


Menu Style: American & Italian

Alcohol Served: Local Beer On Tap, Full Bar

Separate Bar Area: YES


Parking: Parking on Street Visible Signage: From Road / Sign on Building / From Highway

Recommended Dishes

Known for their hand breaded tenderloins, pasta, and beer selection.

Restaurant Photo

Website Phone Directions

Restaurant Information:

Phone: 765-388-2777

1326 Broad Street
New Castle, IN 47362

The Restaurant is part of the following trails:

Previous Stop Back to Trail Next Stop